How can we trust the Bible?
The Bible is the most published book in history. It has been translated into obscure languages and dialects. Authors have commented on it, preached from it, and prayed through it; presidents and prime ministers have been inaugurated by it; and people have burned and banned it. In a society that deems the Bible as merely a mythological text, AllScripture’s mission is to defend its authority as the very Word of God.
Part of defending the authority of Scripture is to acknowledge its dual human and divine authorship. It can be difficult to accept that the Bible is the Word of God, knowing that it was authored by people. However, as this post will introduce, the Word of God can only be deemed as such if God has been intimately involved in its authorship.
The Reliability of Scripture
The question contains three primary theological points to consider, namely, the reliability of Scripture, the authorship of Scripture, and the depravity of humanity. On this occasion, rather than touching on the doctrines of sin and human depravity, I am going to respond to the question presupposing their realities. For the question assumes within itself that fallible human beings cannot accurately produce an inerrant, infallible, and divinely inspired text.
Even though human beings are not perfect, it is entirely possible for fallible people to author reliable literature. For instance, a person is more than capable of producing a telephone book that accurately indexes their friends' or family members’ contact details. Even a high school student can provide perfect answers to an exam and receive full marks.
In these examples, we see that it is possible for fallible people to produce inerrant text. If we deny that fallible people can produce inerrant scripture, we must consequently discard any literature produced by a human author, including all books, academic journal articles, or textbooks, for they are all authored by fallible human beings.
The question we are asking is not simply whether we can trust any work written by people, but rather we are asking whether we can trust people to produce a divine text. We can rephrase this question by saying: “How can we trust that the Bible is divinely inspired if it was written by people?”
This presents to us a fair question. I certainly would not trust human ideas of who God is, if God was not involved in the process. In fact, throughout history, human beings have produced thousands of “sacred texts” that claim to represent God.
We cannot determine what has been divinely inspired, solely through human intellect alone. If we did, we ourselves would be the sole determinants for defining who God is. But God has not left the revelation of His existence and character to mere human ideas alone.
If there is no authority beyond man to determine what is true about God, then all human ideas (i.e., religions), regardless of fundamental contradictions, would be considered equally true. However, if God exists, then He would be the conclusive determinant of what is true about Himself. Thus, God needs to reveal Himself to His creation and be involved in the process of preserving and propagating this revelation throughout history in order to affirm who He truly is.
The method God uses to reveal, preserve, and propagate His character is through the medium of writing. God has inspired the canon of Scripture by superintending the writing of the prophets and apostles to reveal who He is to humanity.
The Incarnation of the Word and the Inspiration of Scripture
The inspiration of scripture can be paralleled with the incarnation of the eternal Word. Jesus Christ is the full revelation of God, similarly the Bible contains historical accounts of God revealing Himself to humanity. Jesus is both human and divine, fully God and fully man, and in the same way, the Bible is divinely and humanly authored.
Jesus is sinless and holy and yet was born through the virgin Mary who was subject to original sin. Similarly, the Bible is perfect and infallible and yet was written by humans. How can a fallible human being “produce” or birth a perfect and sinless Jesus? How can fallible authors produce holy scripture?
The answer is found in Luke 1:35 where the angel Gabriel says to Mary, “The Holy Spirit will come upon you, and the power of the Most High will overshadow you”. It is through the Holy Spirit and the sovereignty of God that a fallible Mary was able to carry and birth Jesus Christ. Specifically, it was the presence of the Holy Spirit descending and operating within the womb of Mary that produced the sinless birth of her son.
However, it was not simply through divine sovereignty alone that Jesus was born, but through the partnership of Mary in carrying the baby to full term that produced the sinless birth of Jesus Christ.
In the same way, God did not simply write His Words on tablets of stone as He did with the ten commandments, but He “overshadowed” the writing of the inspired text to produce inerrant scripture. God superintended the final production of scripture as the authors wrote their words on the parchment.
The Greek word used for “overshadow” is episkiazo (ἐπισκιάζω), meaning “to cast shade upon”. It speaks of the immediate presence of the Holy Spirit in the process of the incarnation. Similarly, as the New Testament authors were writing their Gospels, epistles and revelations to their respective audiences, the Holy Spirit was present in the production of the text and preserved them to become sacred scripture.
We read in Acts 1:8 that the same Holy Spirit that had overshadowed Mary was poured out upon the Apostles to be witnesses of the resurrection of Jesus Christ, “… when the Holy Spirit comes upon you to be my witnesses”. Therefore in the same way, the authors of Scripture were indwelt with the Holy Spirit, and their writings were superintended by God to produce an inspired text.
The Authorship of Scripture
Read: 2 Peter 1:21; 2 Timothy 3:16
Peter helps us understand the role of the Holy Spirit in the inspiration of Scripture through this imagery: “for no prophecy was ever made by an act of human will, but men moved by the Holy Spirit spoke from God” (2 Peter 1:21). Peter, the fisherman, understood the idea of human-divine authorship through an image of a ship driven by the wind.
The wind is an invisible force that exerts its “power” over the boat and fishermen to direct their movements. Fishermen, therefore, were carried along or moved by the wind to lead them through the sea. In the same way, the men who wrote scripture were carried along by the Holy Spirit to lead them to write.
Obviously, imagery is a limited way to describe in human terms what actually occurred supernaturally in the birth of Jesus Christ, and the inspiration of Scripture. However, the truth remains that anything that claims to be of divine origin must be influenced by God Himself. We can trust that the Scriptures were divinely inspired because of the role of the Holy Spirit in producing the inspired text.
When we analyse further of the parallels of the virgin birth and the inspiration of Scripture, we find that the authors of Scripture, through whom the text was written, were not themselves inspired. Mary was sinful and fallible; otherwise, she would not need to give birth to a saviour, and she, herself, would qualify to serve as the saviour of the world. Mary was sinful; however, she did give birth to a sinless Jesus Christ, for whatever the Holy Spirit overshadows will always result in perfection.
In the same way, the authors themselves were fallible, but the Scripture they produced was inerrant because the Holy Spirit was involved in the production of the text. We can, therefore, trust that the Bible was divinely inspired, not only because it was written by human authors, but because it was written through the influence of the Holy Spirit.
As we conclude this brief analysis of the reliability and authorship of Scripture, let us dive a little deeper into the divine authorship of the Bible. Paul outlined this concept in his second pastoral letter to Timothy, where he writes: “All Scripture is God-breathed” (2 Timothy 3:16).
The word “God-breathed” is what is considered as an “hapax legomena”, a word that only occurs once in the entire Bible. It comes from the Greek word “theopneustos” (θεοπνευστος), meaning “breathed out by God”, and comes from the two root words theos, (“God”) and pneo (“breathe out”). It refers to the exhalation of the breath of God when producing the words of scripture.
In this context, the Holy Spirit is depicted as the breath of God. Just as we exhale in speech, God’s breath, His Spirit, is found in the holy scriptures. Therefore, God is near to those who read the Scriptures, for he has been intimately involved in its production and its preservation, and thus, can be relied upon to reveal His true character and nature to us within it.
Certainly, it would be difficult to trust a sacred text written by man alone, however, we can trust that the Bible is divinely inspired because God has claimed to be its co-author.